Finished the whole game, including the postgame and all DLCs, without using Extra Mode, out of sheer defiance of most guides on the game I've ever read.
This game is an incredibly fun time, but, can be roughly divided into two theatres. You have to play the action game part pretty competently, or you'll just die. But, if you don't play the RPG part competently, then you'll do so little damage, and take so much damage, that your fights become hopeless. So, to thrive in this game, you must play both sides equally well...
...And, unlike most open-ended RPGs like this, I actually did really well, I think. Once it started to click, I came up with my own build, pivoting when I needed to, and prevailed over most every boss. And, well, much like Nioh 2, another game that I love, the bosses are fantastic, and there's a ton of depth to engaging each boss with each playstyle. The action side of the game tests everything, positioning, timing, judgment, and I found a valid use for every move I was given.
But, there are a few caveats... First of all, most guides I've found online will point you towards avoiding playing the game-- Use Extra Mode, or any number of invincibility or infinite MP builds. This isn't necessarily a BAD thing, I think it's great that this game has exploits. But, it could give you the wrong impression if you play the game and follow a guide. You can certainly find your way without one, and I was able to cover my weaknesses every time. And... The other Caveat is, if you don't like postgame content, you should avoid the DLC. The DLC extends the postgame, and that's its primary purpose. There are some lovely references to other popular FF games, but the main story's ending is conclusive enough. You don't really need the DLC, if you're just here for the story.
So basically:
- I think this game's gameplay is astoundingly well designed, with exceptional combat and fairly intuitive RPG elements.
- The postgame was great fun. The best decision I made was playing it without using a guide or extra mode to cheese the game.
- The story's pretty cool actually (I didn't say this in the review proper, but, it's true)
- Ignore the DLC until you get access to the postgame. If you really like the postgame, buy the DLC. It's a whooole lot more of the same! And, I personally loved it.
