Manor Lords

刚买的时候：哇，题材好新，游戏框架yyds！牛博一！ 玩了7小时：这游戏除了题材框架，就是个半成品么，过了那么久，有实质性更新否？ 最后，我很少给游戏打差评，除非我真的绷不住了！

Still just as empty as when it released. The game was only ever about visual appeal to draw in the crowd. Further more i was banned from all social platforms just because i voiced my opinion about how this was a number 1 wishlisted for a while only because it looked good. The game at best is a pre - release beta. You can get maybe a good 25-50hrs out of this before its just redundant and repetitive. The game was done way before launch, just so they could hype sales, and yet here we are. Still poking a dead animal with a stick waiting for it to do something. Waste of money, the gaming industry really is just dying.

It is a pretty fun premise. It is worth poking around and the beginning of the game is quite fun. Bonus points for being unique. The not recommended status is because this early release game seems unlikely to ever graduate to a proper game. I did not play for a year and almost nothing improved in game. The balance of the game (money and time) is not well calibrated and I suppose will never be.

Manor Lords — игра с огромным потенциалом, который уже два года так и остаётся потенциалом Впервые играл в Manor Lords где-то в августе 2025 года. На момент того времени игра показалось мне интересной, по началу... В ходе игры я выяснил, что торговля работает не так, как это обычно в играх. Обычно, что бы купить предмет тебе нужно заплатить пошлину в виде 10 серебряных, но в таком случае, что либо покупать становится слишком дорого. Я подумал, что всё дело в том, что я торгую с "чужеземцами" и в окне торговли отключил торговлю с ними. Но торговля остановилось. В окне я увидел уведомление, что торговля прекращена. Без объяснения причины. Пошевелив своими извилинами я смекнул, что вероятнее всего дело в политике, что мне нужно дружить с соседями, дабы те начали со мной торговать. И опять НО. Они вообще не хотят со мной дружить(( На сколько я понял, эта механика ещё не была доработана, ведь в строке отображения отношений у меня ничего не было. Просто пустое поле. "Ну, игра не так давно вышла, тем более студия маленькая, скоро доработают :3" подумал я, но нет... Прошло 2 года с релиза, а так таковой политики в игре нет. Я соглашусь с мнением о том, что возможно я не до конца понял всю проработанность торговли в этой игре, но политика... Невозможно создавать союзы, нельзя составлять торговые соглашения, невозможно при ВОЙНЕ навязать требования в виде вассалитета или же аннексии территории. Кста, анексить территорию можно только за 2к очков влияния, что абсолютно убивает смысл в войне за 500 очков, ведь кроме монет и "отказа на какие-то территории" (я так и не понял, на какие именно...) ты больше ничего не можешь сделать. Самой по себе политики так таковой в игре нет, ты можешь только объявить войну, которая идёт в пакете "бомж война" за 500 и "лакшери война" за 2000. Кто-то скажет, что бы начать нормально торговать нужно завассалить территорию, но какой смысл, если дойдя до первой войны ты можешь сразу начинать другую, но нееееееет, тебе ведь нужна "лакшери война", так что сиди и копи 2000 очков в это время развиваясь, что бы просто город был красивый. Кстати, по сути, кроме красивого города в один момент отпадает смысл в так таковом развитии, ведь ты всё равно можешь нанять ополчение, а в остальном ничего прям полезного ты не получаешь, кроме денег, куда их только деть ?.... На месяц войны, что бы просто разбить армию противника, тебе нужно условно 300 серебра, которые не сложно накопить без супер-пупер мегаполиса. Мб в этом и смысл игры, что бы построить москов сити в средневековье, но бляяя, всё это так душно, что желания особого нет. В остальном, играть смысла нет. Если кто хочет, просто позалипать на красивые домики и на "огромную армию" (которую по сути задействовать некуда), то наверное вам зайдёт. Лично для меня, без политики и нормальной торговли, я могу и в Cities: Skylines поиграть. Очень бы хотелось, что бы они допили игру, но если честно, вряд ли всё, что я хочу и хотят иные игроки, вообще будет в игре когда либо.

这更新更个寂寞，更新了什么东西 都没新玩法

Is this game great? Its awesome! Would I recommend buying it? Unfortunately, not right now. Manor Lords is truly something special. No one has ever made a game quite like this before. Its approach is completely different from anything we know from other city builders. It feels real, authentic, and organic, while offering interesting and unique mechanics. The graphics are beautiful, and the potential for the future is enormous. However, new players should stay away from it for now because this game gives you the feeling of being in a toxic relationship. It's not that the developers took the money and went on an endless vacation. Quite the opposite! The team puts a tremendous amount of effort into optimization, bug fixes, and countless small improvements that may seem insignificant at first glance but make a huge difference when combined. But how good are 1000 bug fixes if we've received almost no new content in the last two years? We've only had 2.5 truly good content updates: the Manor update, the AI villages (which, in my opinion, work terribly, but it's still nice to see something "alive" on the map that wasn't created by the player), and the Tier 3 houses. And that's about it. Yes, we've also received new maps, but that's not what we're waiting for. And that's exactly the problem: the patient has been in a coma for two years now. His condition is stable, but he's still in a coma. If you look at the cover art of Manor Lords, you'll see a beautiful medieval city in the background. But at the current pace of development, we might not get there for another ten years. There is still so much content missing from this game. I think we've only received about 30% of what we should have by now. And I'm not even talking about all the missing mechanics. I wish I could build a large, beautiful stone city. I wish we would get more story in the game, engage in meaningful politics on both a regional and local level, and be forced to make decisions with both positive and terrible consequences. Who knows, maybe even have the opportunity to become king and turn our region into the capital. I wish we had mounted military units, barracks, and so much more, along with a more complex economy. And I know this studio is capable of delivering all of that. But at the current pace, GTA 7 will probably be released first, and that's a really big problem. Until more starts happening, until we begin receiving new content on a regular basis, I simply cannot recommend this game to anyone. We're already on version 0.8.9, almost at a full release, yet it still feels more like version 0.5.

2024年买的，后续更新极其糟糕，制作组根本就没好好工作。烽沙试玩版都比这个强。

I purchased this over a year ago and initially loved the game. The graphics are amazing and gameplay feels different than others set in this era. That said, once you learn the basics and play through a few times you end up getting stuck due to the lack of late game content and unfinished perk trees. Update after update over the past year have primarily fixed elements of this same short playthrough experience vs. completing major features that are greyed out and "coming soon". Still following the updates as it is a great game conceptually, but it's currently shelved on my playlist until it's closer to a 1.0 state.

This game is charming, addictive, and looks amazing. I have played through various updates and I believe the game is moving just as advertised. It was said from the beginning that this is a passion project. I read complaints about the RNG resources, dead end features, and features not available yet. I don't agree with these complains. The RNG resources allows each game I play to feel unique as if I were settling the unknown. It is okay for one playthrough to have an easier time than another. The dead end features are a thing, but the game is early access and there is more than enough content now to be worth the $40 tag. To summarize, you have to understand this game is early access and is constantly changing. The features that are present are worth the price tag. I have had no issues with currently available gameplay elements like battles, farming, building, or anything. I think once you get the learning curve, it is an enjoyable experience that rewards you for coming back and trying a new playthrough. I look forward to see what Manor Lords becomes as time goes on

It's been around a year now with no real meaningful content being added. Instead, we've had minor balancing patches spread apart in 4 updates every 3 months that go "X building now consumes Y amount of resources" or "Citizens no longer consume Y amount of resources". Game is deservedly getting grilled for being stuck in this state despite the massive financial influx ever since it released in early access. Odds are, the developer is going to do one more balancing patch for 0.9 and an unceremonious 1.0 launch that won't look very different from what's in the game now.