Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter

[h1] PROS: [/h1] [list] [*] 5 interesting cases, each with its own unique story and mystery. [*] Decent graphics that still hold up reasonably well. [*] Good voice acting that helps bring the characters to life. [*] You can customize and disguise Sherlock, which adds a bit of fun and variety. [*] Moral choices at the end of each case. [*] Some genuinely clever puzzles and deductions that make you feel like a detective. [*] The investigation mechanics become more enjoyable once you understand how the game works. [/list] [h1] CONS: [/h1] [list] [*] Whoever designed the first case deserves to be forced to play it for 100000 years! The forest chase sequence combined with the awful controls is incredibly frustrating and nearly made me quit the game. [*] Terrible camera handling and controls. It takes a long time to get used to them, and they never feel truly comfortable. [*] The game often hides progression behind tiny, easy-to-miss details. For example, you may find a postcard containing all the information you need, but the game refuses to progress until you inspect the back and make a specific deduction. [*] The highlighting feature is not very helpful, as many important objects are still difficult to spot. [*] Sherlock is surprisingly unlikeable at times and often comes across as a complete jerk. [*] A ridiculous amount of QTE events. [*] Lots of loading screens when fast traveling. [*] Some puzzles are poorly designed and simply not fun. Pushing boxes around at a snail's pace or following barely visible scent trails while playing as a dog quickly becomes tedious. [*] The autosave system can be frustrating and often saves at the worst possible moments. [*] Certain obstacle room puzzles rely more on trial and error than actual problem solving. [*] The game occasionally mistakes pixel hunting for detective work. [/list] [h1] OVERALL: [/h1] This game has a lot of flaws, and honestly the first case almost made me quit more times than I can count. Between the clunky controls, frustrating chase sequences, and obscure objectives, the opening hours are easily the worst part of the experience. However, once you get past that rough start, the game becomes surprisingly enjoyable. The cases become more interesting, the mysteries are engaging, and the deduction system starts to shine. While the gameplay is often held back by questionable design decisions, there is still a solid detective adventure hidden underneath all the frustration. I bought the game for around 5€ during a sale, and that's exactly how I would recommend getting it. At a heavily discounted price, it's worth experiencing for the stories and investigations alone. Just be prepared to deal with some outdated mechanics, frustrating puzzles, and a lot of patience-testing moments along the way.

Sıkı bir Sherlock Holmes okuru olarak Sherlock Holmes oyunlarının genel olarak zayıf ve hikaye açısından yetersiz olduğunu söyleyebilirim. Ama The Devil`s Daughter tam tersine güzel bir oyundu. Davalar her ne kadar kolay olsa da bazılarının orta seviyede olduğunu söyleyebilirim. Hikayesiyse ilgi çekici ve çok ters köşeli. Sherlock`un görünüşünü değiştirebilmemiz ve Londra`nın hoş sokaklarında gezebilmemiz de oyunun artı yönlerinden biri. Yan karakterler de güzel yazılmış ve oyunun fiyatı indirime girdiği zaman oldukça uygun. Çıtır çerezlik dedektif oyunu. Sherlock Holmes severiyseniz oyun akar. Grafikleri de devre göre ne fazla göz yorar ne de çirkin. Ufak tefek optimizasyon hataları ve yer yer bugları olsa da çokta rahatsız etmiyor.

咋说呢，这代，他可以说是全方面的进步，但都是全方面的退步，重点讲讲。因为是罪与罚的续作嘛，制作组恐怕是为了在原有的基础上做多创新，于是加入了很多的新内容，但是，他加的东西给人的感觉像是因为前作的大获成功，使他们不想跳出自己的舒适区，说白了就是想做改变，但又不敢，于是你就能在里面玩到各方面都与前作一致，但哪哪哪不对劲的作品。首先就是贝克街终于有地图了，福尔摩斯的家不局限于一间房子，你可以去底下瞎逛逛，还是个不错的优点，然后，本作的福尔摩斯形象也与罪与罚的形象有些出入，可能是这代多了个莫里亚蒂女儿养父的身份，这代的福尔摩斯多了几分人情味，与罪与罚中只为探案而生仿佛无情机器一般的名侦探有所不同，我也还挺喜欢这代的形象塑造的。然后，优点讲完了，对，他这代就这点优点，接下来听我慢慢吐槽。首先，他们试图建造一作城镇，从贝克街的建设可以看出来，但是，这作城镇除了必要的地点可谓是又大又空，你没有任何可交流可互动的地方存在，唯一的作用就是让你找不到路，在罪与罚里，当你传送至一个区域时，当你到那就意味着你真正到那了，但这作不同，他会把你丢在一座大地图里，让你自己去找你需要去的地方再开始探索，严重影响探案的节奏，而且更无语的是，当你找到你要找的地方时，下次你就可以直接传送过去不需要再找路，仿佛之前的那段寻路就是为了故意卡你时长一样，其次，这作真的是加入了致死量的小游戏，平均每个章节都会塞一两个你没见过的玩法，严重拖累游戏节奏，尤其是第二章最意义不明的神庙逃亡，你都不知道他存在的意义是什么，当然虽然可以跳过，但也减弱了游戏的代入感。最后，本作的所有，记住是所有案件质量都不敬人意，本作总共5个章节，其中案件只有4个，对比罪与罚可谓是少的可怜，同时，本作的案件质量也拉的彻底，不论是案件本身还是探案的过程，对比罪与罚都进行了全面的缩水，几个的线索基本都是把能点全点一遍就可以得到，根本没有了前作为了一个线索要去解开另一个谜题那种环环相扣的联系感，甚至连嫌疑人审问，研究室研究，尸体解剖这种最经典的探查手段在本作也被删的基本上干干净净，与之增加的是不知何意味的场景解密，潜行，而且占了主导地位，完全把推理解密这一基本概念给篡改了。并且本作是有一条贯穿全篇的主线，但是这条主线写的也是真心不咋地，尤其，是他没有一个像样的结尾，我之前也说过，前作的案件在解决完之后，没有一个后日谈就快速进入下一个案件导致整体有些突兀，但前作罪与罚本身就是多个单元剧所组成的游戏，他没有主线，但恶魔之女不一样，他是有的，并且最后一章还专门用来讲这个故事，把推理都彻底抛弃了，可故事的结尾，是真的让人不知所云，他根本就不算烂尾，因为他还没有尾就放ed，这给那些正真在乎这条故事线的人根本没有释放情绪的空间，是真的很不负责的一个做法。反正这部作品，让想玩推理游戏的没玩到好推理，让想看故事的没看到好故事，也侧面证明了罪与罚的含金量，整体不推荐，罪与罚本身较短，就10小时左右的时长，这部更短，7小时不到就打通了，真心不值。

[h1] 趁著本次2026年夏日促銷，福爾摩斯系列游戲全體打折的契機，作爲一名小説、影視、游戲等各方面福爾摩斯的骨灰級粉絲，以我自己的視角給大家推薦一下本系列的購買建議： [/h1] [b] 1. [/b]第一梯隊最建議購買的是前作“罪與罰”，整體游玩下來體驗感最好，也是我最喜歡的一部；但是短板也很明顯：劇情連貫性有一點差 [b] 2. [/b]其次是本作“惡魔之女”，是繼“罪與罰”之後Frogwares Studio推出的另一部，在劇情演繹方面對比前作得到了優化，這一作比較建議新手玩家入門。但是，這一作的優化比前作退步了很多，在游玩你能感覺到很明顯的卡頓甚至會掉幀，這一點的體驗感很差；（有一點劇情，介意者請勿點擊[spoiler]其次在後半段劇情有點誇張讓人摸不着頭腦 [/spoiler]）最後，這一步如果想深度了解劇情的朋友，還建議一起游玩本系列另外一部“福爾摩斯的遺囑” [b] 3. [/b]在第二點我剛才提到的“福爾摩斯的遺囑”，在幾年前的一次重大更新中已加入包括中文等語言，因此不用擔心語言問題，放心游玩；因爲本作推出時間較早，因此畫面沒有前兩作的精細，但是劇情也很不錯，且在一定關係上與“惡魔之女”有劇情連結，沒有看過福爾摩斯系列的朋友可以先玩本作，再游玩“惡魔之女” [b] 4. [/b]福爾摩斯《第一章》，這一作翻譯有問題，英文原意是：Chapter One，原意為第一個故事，講的是年輕的福爾摩斯在沒有來到倫敦前在母親去世的島上開展的探案過程，但中文翻譯卻變成了“第一章故事”。。。這一作在引擎與畫面都得到了很大提升，跟上了游戲市場上大部分游戲的脚步，但是這一作只推薦福爾摩斯系列的粉絲購買（粉絲都要仔細斟酌），首先這一作畫面升級這個還是給按贊，但并不代表著一作很好玩：作業感很嚴重，製作組想把探案世界作到開放式可以理解，但是本作的開放世界做的非常無聊，包括交戰系統也只是在一遍遍重複；綫索指引對新手很不友好，很容易卡關。這一作總體而言不建議新手購買 [b] 5. [/b]福爾摩斯“覺醒”，這一作是2008年的“覺醒”重製版，改作沿用了福爾摩斯《第一章》的角色模型，可以看作Frogwares Studio想把本作做成與第一章同一世界觀裏。本作游玩體驗不算太差，但有前作的表現，所以這一作只建議在前面幾部游玩過後再嘗試購買；本作融合了克蘇魯元素也算是這一作的一個亮點吧。 [b] 6. [/b]剩下的幾步因為年代太過於古老，且語言支持很少，就暫時不推薦大家游玩了，看看網路攻略就行（還是說兩部吧，一部銀耳環也是案件推理，但年代久遠，不支持中文等；巴斯克維爾的獵犬，找茬小游戲，可以練習你的反應以及你的英文能力） [h3]最後：我的語言組織表達能力不是很好，如果有邏輯不通之處還請各位多多包涵 [/h3]

If you loved Crimes and Punishments, this is a must-play The deduction mechanics are brilliant, requiring actual logic to connect clues and accuse the right suspect. It brings a darker, more cinematic atmosphere to Sherlock's world A fantastic puzzle-deduction game that is incredibly satisfying to 100% complete.

finished all achievements in 15h so its easy to play, not the best graphics cus being an old game, yet amazing story again. what bothers me a little is that sherlock being less mature in this game than the others. yet it is still an amazing game, recommending :thumbsup:

！[h3] 也是好久没写评测了 [/h3] [b] 《恶魔之女》相比前作《罪与罚》来说，太草率了，剧情短，流程短，连每个案子都草草结束，特别是倒数第二个案子和结局，突然之间嘎巴一下就没了。 就是加了很多几乎不可能自己想到的解密，话说神庙那部分解密诗人啊。好在可以跳过解密且不影响成就，还算可以接受，剩下就没什么要说了，剧情一般，案子推理反转也一般，甚至画面相比前作也看不出来啥提升...[/b] [b] 这B Frogwares 看来就是打算抱着福尔摩斯这个IP吃老本到死了，下作可能不玩[/b] [h1] 5.7/10 [/h1]

Az elmebeteg picsa nem kellett volna bele, ezen kívűl fain...

与上一作一样，几个案件互相独立，但本作多了一条福尔摩斯女儿[spoiler]其实是莫里亚蒂的女儿[/spoiler]线始终贯穿在各个小案件中。游戏难度有两个，敏锐的侦探比侦探大师简单，后者应该多了个人物肖像有时间限制。人物肖像的细节比上一作多了可选项，选错了会刻画失败且无法重来，但是可以通过看右侧模糊提示选择正确答案。成就方面真的比上一作轻松太多了，首先是删掉了那个要求得出全部结论的成就，其次删掉了高尚的品格成就，这样就可以按照自己喜好判处是否有罪。有的小游戏不能跳过有成就，其他该跳就跳别折磨自己，尤其神庙里面的小游戏。

i feel intelligent