Gerda: A Flame in Winter

挺好的剧情游戏，麻雀篇章比较爽枪在手想杀谁杀谁，不像护士跟个孙子一样天天低声下气。 游戏玩法有点像极乐迪斯科一样靠人物性能去做成功判定，这点我很喜欢。 最大缺点是建模粗糙以及落后的存档机制。感觉可以做成类似底特律那种存档方式或者按篇章或者每天存档，这个自动存档方式对成就党和想完整体验剧情每个分支的人不友好。

Such a specific slice of WW2 European strife. I dated a man from this region for several years so seeing it come to life in a game is really interesting to me. Also, it's very moving, sad, and fun to play.

An okay game, but for whatever reason in the final confrontation in the forest, despite my having several Mental Energies in each category (about 2-3 each) the game refused to allow me to use these mental energies to convince a certain character not to shoot a different character, so of course that character died. The ending I strove for was ruined by some stupid glitch. I replayed the ending FOUR times, the glitch persisted no matter what. L software.

Like a Choose Your Own Adventure With Limited Gameplay Objective Review 6 of 5 must play. 5 of 5 great story great game-play. 4 of 5 great story average game-play. 3 of 5 average story great game-play. 2 of 5 give it a go only if it's you're favourite genre. 1 of 5 play if you have nothing better to do, 0 of 5 play if you're a masochist. -1 of 5 avoid. Gerda: A Flame in Winter Gerda's story score is 4 of 5. Gerda: A Flame in Winter Liva's story score is 4 of 5. Subjective Review I've played several games by DONTNOD. The stories have never disappointed me. Gerda/Liva are no exception to this. The choices you make having real circumstances that lead to good/terrible paths. This could've been a straight text adventure, but then I wouldn't have bothered. If I'm going to read a book I want one that I can curl up with on a couch/bed. The graphical side is simply amazing, love this style. Isometric view, nah, don't like it. But this not being an action game at all, I decided to give it a go. The music, very well done. It would be great if someone could take the time to put this story and all the choices made into a 3rd/1st person shooter. There's definitely enough material that such could be done. Great stories are missed by a majority of gamers who don't want to bother with a game that has very little input from the controller they're holding. Having stated that I must say, there were times that were absolutely jarring. The sounds of a shot and the blood that is presented along with the very lifelike falling of a now lifeless body is very well done. Shockingly well done, actually. Didn't expect it at times, which actually made it seem more real. There's a lot to be said about a story that can realistically turn out completely different than you thought it would. I never play this kind of game more than once. I try to treat them like real life, where I must live with the consequences I meet because of the choices I make. It gives me much to think upon long after I've put the game to rest. If I replay it to various endings I soon forget the game. Pay attention to the Objective Review. If you like lots of gameplay, don't bother. The extra content, Liva's story is very short. Kind of ends in the middle of a story. To me, they should have made Liva's story first, then carried on Gerda's story with the results from Liva's story, and made it all one game.

Great game. And I like how it is complicated from the perspective of choices you make. I strongly disagree with people who writing about sympathizing nazi german, it is shown from the perspective of people who can't be a B.J. Blazkowicz or Terminator and go kill all german nazies at once. People make choices and sacrifices, which feels more realistic when you have hard feelings to help healing nazi soldier (but on the other hand you are on enemy's territory as you country is occupied, to get intel and their disposition). Some people just have to play Wolfenstein instead.

10/10

我是真的不想帮反抗军，没有革命牺牲精神，只求安稳度过难关。

我把大伙儿玩死了

这类游戏里最值得游玩的DLC之一，在观点和视角上都得到了充分的补充，且和正片没有特定游玩顺序，不做任何剧透只谈游戏的话，先DLC后正片是“人定胜天由你选择开拓出的道路”，先正片后DLC是“在已知命运的前提下，你如何践行意志”

——《Gerda: A Flame in Winter / 格尔达：寒冬之火》，-80%折扣叠加捆绑包“Gerda: A Flame in Winter - Modstand Bundle”，8.40元，25/11/29入。 ——二战题材叙事向轻 RPG，改编自丹麦抵抗运动真实历史，以边境小镇普通护士的视角切入战争末期的灰色日常。没有枪林弹雨的大场面，全靠层层递进的道德困境与细腻的人物群像撑起叙事，是近年小众历史题材里完成度很高的作品，玩法偏轻度，更适合剧情向玩家。 ——综合评分：7.8/10 ——世界观与主线剧情：故事发生在1945年2月的丹麦边境小镇廷莱弗，二战已接近尾声，德国占领军的统治却愈发严酷。 主角格尔达・拉尔森是一名年轻护士，身上流着一半德国、一半丹麦的血脉，在小镇上过着隐忍平静的生活。直到某天，她的丹麦丈夫安德斯因参与抵抗组织炸毁工厂的行动被逮捕，即将被处决。留给格尔达的只有五天时间，她必须在占领军、地下抵抗组织、立场暧昧的村民之间周旋，利用自己的身份、人脉与仅有的资源，想尽办法救出丈夫，同时还要保护身边的亲友不被牵连。 ——游戏玩法：带轻度养成与资源管理的互动叙事游戏。 1.时间管理：游戏以“天”为单位推进，每天的时间有限，玩家只能从多个地点里选2-3个前往。去了农场就没时间去镇公所，帮了抵抗组织就没法去探望被捕的亲友，所有选择都有明确的机会成本，不存在全事件触发的完美路线。 2.对话与道德抉择：每个关键对话都有多个方向，既可以靠共情博取信任，也可以靠谎言蒙混过关，甚至能投靠占领军换取便利。没有绝对正确的选项：救了一个村民，可能会暴露抵抗组织的据点；帮德军治疗伤员，会被同乡视作叛徒；哪怕是出于善意的选择，也可能引发更坏的结果。主角半德半丹的身份被深度融入玩法：既能靠德国血统获得占领军的初步信任，也会因此被丹麦村民猜忌，天然处在立场撕裂的中心。 3.性格技能：通过日记反思每日经历获得技能点，可解锁共情、冷静、话术、医疗等专属能力，开启特殊对话选项。 4.资源管理：药品、食物、证件、燃料都是稀缺物资，今天分给了求助的难民，后续自己救人时可能就无药可用，每一次物资分配都需要权衡。 ——游戏优点： 1.手绘北欧印象派画风，冷调的冬日雪景、昏黄的室内灯光、萧瑟的边境小镇，视觉上沉静又压抑，完美贴合战争末期“寒冬将尽、黎明未至”的氛围，印象派美术氛围感拉满。 2.不同于多数二战游戏的战场爽感，本作把视角对准了大时代里的普通人，所有事件都贴合丹麦被占领时期的真实社会生态。没有刻意的煽情与英雄主义，战争的残酷全藏在日常的两难里：为了活下去，每个人都在妥协、挣扎、守住自己的底线，叙事克制却后劲十足。 3.游戏里几乎没有脸谱化的反派：德军里有良知未泯的普通士兵，抵抗组织里有冲动鲁莽的极端者，村民里有善良的相助者也有告密的投机者。每个选择的代价都清晰可见，不会有做了好事就该有好报回应，却能真切体会到乱世里小人物的无力与坚守。 ——典型的“小而沉”的历史叙事佳作，不追求场面与玩法复杂度，专注把战争里普通人的故事讲得扎实动人，适合喜欢慢节奏剧情、二战历史题材、道德抉择类游戏的玩家。26/07/18