dead game with the same 50 or so players. you will run into the same people with the same names every single game, in a game where you can name yourself literally anything. games take anywhere from half an hour to an hour or more to fill, and if even one person leaves before the 10 second countdown hits zero, it resets and you have to wait for another player to join. also there is literally nothing to do while you wait for the lobby to fill, and if you're afk for too long you get kicked for idling. the community is very toxic and cringy and a majority of the roles are either unfair or unfun or both. evil roles are insanely ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥: not only will you almost never have a full team, but there is so much ♥♥♥♥ that can kill you, it's like walking on egg shells, and god forbid you get a neutral killing role like werewolf or juggernaut. with those roles you're on a team by yourself and if you make even one mistake you either die, get hung early game, or get hung end game by the faction that has majority. so unless if you are either insanely lucky, or in the case of serial killer and arsonist, you get carried (because there can be more than one serial killer/arsonist), or you get lucky with amnesiac and get a cheap win off of remembering a neutral killing role, you will lose. town however is the most one-sided faction in the game. multiple roles that can find evils and protect other townies. if there are 2 or more doctors, crusaders, or bodyguards, they can do something called chaining where they are literally unstoppable unless if you're like arsonist or something or the other townies just had surgery done for a lobotomy and forget they're town. speaking of neutral roles, executioner. you are better off admitting you're executioner, telling the lobby who your target is, and literally begging on your hands and knees than actually trying any kind of strategy, cause that ♥♥♥♥ will never work, same with jester, also there's a chance that your target will just die night 1 so have fun being turned into a jester and then probably dying before you can be hung because people are ♥♥♥♥♥-whipped ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ that don't know how to have fun. as survivor stronger evils like werewolf and juggernaut will just kill you for no reason even though you could literally be the extra vote they need to win the game. as pirate you'll die long before you get the 2 wins you need because have fun winning 2 different 1/3s before you die. as guardian angel evils will deliberately kill your target and turn you into survivor or even just kill you too. and you're probably thinking "if there are so many miserable, god-awful roles, why not just use scrolls?" scrolls are a ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ scam, they only boost your chances of getting a role, they don't guarantee it, and they sure as hell don't work. in fact, scrolls are so ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥, some people are genuinely convinced that scrolls for some roles just don't work. also why are there no juggernaut scrolls? also i love how they can be bothered to change the names of escort and consort to tavern keeper and bootlegger because they're woke sheep, but they cant even be bothered to change their icons when you go to buy scrolls for those roles. the game is way too luck based for any fun to be derived from it, unless if you're insanely lucky or something. also the amount of people in this game that genuinely have autism, downs, tourettes, or something similar, is ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ mind-blowing. also the amount of game throwers, trolls, teamers, and other kinds of players that ruin the experience for everyone else and they don't get banned, meanwhile i get banned for throwing even though i'm literally not throwing and i'm just a new player and i get banned for leaving games even though me leaving doesn't impact the game in any way whatsoever, like when you leave as werewolf or juggernaut, roles where you are on a team alone by yourself, or when you are solo mafia or solo coven, it affects only me, yet i am still punished. and why appeal? the game is dead, the forums are dead and look like they haven't been updated in decades, your appeal won't be responded to and even if it is it'll be denied. and good luck getting all the achievements. you have to get 25 wins with every role which is like 1k+ wins total, and thousands more games where you will lose and lose and lose again. also some of the achievements literally just fall into the category of game throwing, like this one achievement as tracker where you have to watch the same person 3 times in a row, why would you ever do that outside of the context of an achievement. also ♥♥♥♥ vampires. like ill just be playing as town and then boom i'm a ♥♥♥♥♥♥ vampire on an undermanned team and then town wins and i'm left to mald with the other people that were turned alongside me. also the way people decide ♥♥♥♥ in town of salem is insane. like i will deadass be killed night 1 because i have an afk name or because i'm at the top of the player list or because my name is similar to someone else's. also why is the browser version not free anymore? idk bruh go play like literally any other game or some ♥♥♥♥ because i guarantee you there are very few games that are worse than this one. also a few things i remembered a few days after writing this. bans work in a very ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ stupid way. first ban is 1 day, 2nd is 3, 3rd is 7, and then your 4th ban is permanent. no game works like this anymore, and remember what i said above about appeals always being denied and the forums being dead. also you will literally never get town, there are far more evil roles than town roles and like i mentioned above scrolls are a coping mechanism. also being the host means literally nothing. back in the day you could start the game early but now a days its just there and it does literally nothing. also playing against executioner sucks if you are a town role that cannot be easily confirmed like medium. you just lose by default. also playing against pirate sucks too because being dueled counts as being role blocked and there is that 1/3 chance that you just die, and pirate has a powerful attack so very few things can protect you from him. update again: executioner literally ruins the game for town investigative roles because if you find someone evil n1 people just think you're an executioner trying to get a townie hung. also people expect you to play the game a certain way, as opposed to how you want to play. you are literally not allowed to play any other way other than the way people expect or you will probably get mass reported and banned (im pretty sure if you receive enough reports you get automatically banned even if said reports are false), or just relentlessly flamed, even though playing the way people expect isn't always the best playstyle.
