Gallipoli

I feel like this is a step back from Isonzo. I'm not having as much fun with this game compared to the previous titles. I think this may be the result of the Officer class (which is my favorite) feeling kinda dull now. They increased the amount of Officer slots per team by 3 but you have dramatically less call-in types. You can call in a large radial bombardment or a linear airstrike... that's it... In most scenarios you just use them on cooldown since they're very strong... and it's just kinda boring. You can put down spawn points as an attacker which is nice but something is just missing from the experience compared to Isonzo. It's really a spectacle in Isonzo when your team or the enemy team drops a big call-in on the point and successfully caps or defends at the last minute. These moment's have felt lacking or entirely absent from the matches I've played in Gallipoli. Gallipoli feels "flat" and almost quiet in a weird way. I've yet to have an "Oh ♥♥♥♥" moment like I've had in Isonzo. Also I've experienced very VERY bad desync issues that are genuinely insanely frustrating. I'm constantly being killed by enemies the frame they appear on my screen from behind corners or various angles or even dying many frames before they even turn the corner. I've died many times to players who aren't even visibly looking in my direction. It's like everyone is playing 1-2 second in the future. I have a wired fiber internet with 40-60ms ping to the servers. It's completely unacceptable for it to feel THIS bad to play. I do not remember Isonzo being this egregious with the desync. I'm also not really enjoying the way the weapons have been rebalanced in this game compared to Isonzo. They're extremely inaccurate now and have a ton of sway. I've experienced several moments where I'm missing shots that look like they should absolutely land and also hitting shots that are off aim. It feels like they added some kind of "bloom" like in certain Battlefield games where weapons have randomized bullet spread patterns at range. I guess this could also be from the insane levels of desync... These experiences while aiming are not because of suppression mechanics just to be clear. I actually like the suppression mechanics in this game which affect aim, reload speed, etc. I just wish the weapons felt good when you weren't suppressed... I think there's a balance issue with Attacking vs Defending. Defending feels very hard and I lose more while Defending and win more while Attacking. Not sure what to do about this but I think some adjustments are needed. I think at a bare minimum for me to recommend this game the devs need to address the desync problems. I can accept some of the changes compared to Isonzo but if the game just feels ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ to play I really can't convince myself to jump in. If I could I would refund this game right now specifically because of the desync issues I've experienced.

While I am a huge fan of the previous games in the series I cannot recommend this game in its current form. It has added many new and good features from the previous titles, yet it falls short in others, and has many problems. I do like many of the additions to the game, however I am going to focus on the negatives due to how bad they make the game over the previous titles. I have hundreds of hours in Isonzo, Tannenberg and Verdun combined. I adored those titles so this is not a review of pure hate. I want to like this game and see it improve. Firstly, the hit registration is atrocious. I have shot at enemies, point blank while aiming down sights, only to get a 'supressed' hit marker multiple times. At first I thought I was just terrible, but after playing for a while it's definitely an issue with the game. Had me gaslighting myself for the first few hours. But it is genuinely the worst hit reg out of any game I've ever played. Pistols are incredibly OP. The worst in the series. In the other games they're quite balanced, but even at a far distance they'll down you and can be an immediate kill up close. So incredibly OP. Due to this in CQB if you come across an enemy with one your only hope is to hip fire and pray you hit. There's also now a bizarre mini game to speed up building wire/MG/anything. Super unnecessary and annoying. Why even add that in an FPS that is clearly trying to make itself more realistic??? There's no smoke. None. Your only hope is the sand the artillery kicks up shielding your advance. Outside of that good luck advancing on a machine gun. You're f@ckd. They've also added a 'panic' feature, which activates whenever bullets or shells land nearby or whenever you stub your toe, making your rifle shake uncontrollably. Clearly added to make suppression a bigger part of the game and to make 'supportive fire' more important for your teammates. Saying this, it seems to activate even if you are a decent distance from the incoming rounds, and especially if a machine gun is firing on your position, so good luck being able to return fire. It just makes the game incredibly tedious. In theory a cool feature, in practice it's atrocious for a shooter. ESPECIALLY in a game where there's constant rounds and artillery coming in. Isn't that meant to be the WHOLE part of the series??? I managed to bizarrely spawn in the enemy HQ a couple times while my squad were pushing up near it, behind multiple enemies. I was able to come up straight from behind them and bayonet 4 of them taking their HQ, before being 1 shot by a pistol - of course! Lastly I want to touch on cross-play. My friend bought the game with me (he's on PS5) and there is no way for me to add him as a friend at all. We have to find a small enough game that's identifiable in order to join each other. Realistically what is the point in having cross-play if you can't play with your mates on console? It just adds easier to kill players for those on PC as they get a very 'minor' aim assist. So minor I don't even think there's a point to having it. I could keep writing but the list is actually exhausting writing. Really let down by this title in its current form.

Oyunun eleştiri almasını anlıyorum eksik noktaları var ama bu oyunu bf1 ile karşılaştırıp olmamış beğenmedim diyenlere aldırış etmeyin çünkü iki oyun birbirinden çok farklı. Eğer karşılaştırmak gerekiyorsa bu oyun Hell let loose olabilir. Merak edenler için oyunda alacağınız paket kozmetik oluyor ben Osmanlı paketini aldım ve buna uygun kıyafetler giyebiliyorsun. Son paketi alırsanız da hem İngiliz hem de Osmanlı ya ait ekstra kıyafetlere erişminiz oluyor. Oyun hakkında olumlu olarak söyleceklerim tabiki atmosfer ve sizi içine çeken Türkçe seslendirmeler ve ayrıca muhteşem müzikler. Evet oyun yavaş ve bu tür için gayet makul bir durum eğer bf1 gibi bir oyun akışı bekliyorsanız bu oyun size göre değil. Oyunda performans olarak sorun yaşamadım gayet akıcı bir şekilde oynayabiliyorum(İ7 11700k + RTX5070+32GB). Eğer VoIP ile iletişim kurabilecek birileri varsa oyun daha da keyifli hale geliyor. Gördüğüm kadarıyla bir eleştiri de oyuncu topluluğuna olacak her timin kendi görevleri var bunlara uygun oynamak gerek ve çoğu tim de subay bulunmuyor hava desteğinden eksik olunca kazanma şansı azalıyor evet oyun FPS fakat herkes görevini yapınca daha çok keyif alacaksınız eminim. Eleştireceğim noktaların başında arkadaşlarınla aynı tim de oynayabilmek zorluğu. Umarım geliştirici ekip bu yorumları okuyordur da buna bir çare üretirler çünkü aynı takımda oynamak için maçlardan çıkmak zorunda kalıyoruz. Pre-squad olarak bir maça eşleşmek belki zor olabilir yada zaman alabilir ama en azından sunucuya girdiğimizde oyunculara tim kurma şansı verilirse arkadaşlarımızı davet ederek tek bir takımda buluşma şansımız olacaktır. Atmosfer + oynanbilirlik + Türkçe seslendirme = 9/10 Bizim yapmamız gereken oyunu bu stüdyo yapmış ve üzerine ciddi mesai harcayarak özen göstermiş. Şahsi görüşüm Her Türk oyun severin mutlaka kütüphanesinde bulunması gereken bir oyun. Kim bilir belki her milli duygularımız kabardığında girer anzak koyunda birkaç düşman öldürür maç sonunda Plevne Marşı dinleriz hep beraber.

12 saat oynadıktan sonra diyeceğim şu, siper savaşları çok iyi ve taktik yaparak ilerlemeniz gerekiyor. Olumsuz yorum yapanların geneli aşırı hızlı oyun sevenler. Simülasyon ve hızlı oyun arasında bir tadı var, oyunun atmosferi ve seslendirmeler çok iyi. Geliştirici ekip için bir tavsiye - Gözcülerin işaretlediği ve uzakta olan düşmanlar UI hedefi kapattığı için görünmüyor ve vurmak imkansız hale geliyor.

I wish I could recommend this. But so much of the game is bizarrely or poorly designed compared to earlier iterations of the same franchise that I really don't know how it came out like this. There are far too many classes and several of the glasses exacerbate the problems I have with the game. There is no reason to play a rifleman: you can't even spawn on your teammates. In exchange you get a slightly reduced weapon sway - so play a Stretcher Bearer or Ammo Holder, because they're riflemen with a much more useful gimmick and they can spawn on their teammates. This sounds like a minor detail but what really happens is people play riflemen and then refuse to play aggressively because it takes an age to get anywhere as it due to the limited spawns. Bombers. This is more a personal gripe than something I think is poorly designed. But who came up with the idea of having multiple players able to play a class with multiple grenades, the same rifle as the rifleman (or PISTOLS, yay!) and the ability to stun willy-nilly due to the possible grenade spam? Engineer and Spotter are such circumstantial roles now beholden to their utility kit. Sounds cool right? Right, well, half of the Engis and Spotters you see won't play with their utility kit anyway. You have two niche roles who once again - in the Signaller and Saboteur Kit can get pistols. The amount of pistols turns a WW1 shooter into a WW2 one. If we had less classes that were more general you could more precisely link them to certain classes, but the amount of kits on multiple classes that allow pistol use turns them from a specialist weapon that helps you identify a class into a lovely game of pistol abuse. This wouldn't be a problem if damage values weren't as rigid as previous entries but they are, so dozens of players will run around with pistols in a WW1 game and liberally miss 5/6 rounds in the time it takes for a rifle to fire two. Great. Still a one hit kill at 90% of the distances you fight at in Gallipoli. This brings me to another point: customisation is a mess. Not in a 'there's no options' or 'this is ahistorical' way, no. Instead I mean it in an identification way, across classes. Most classes can be made visually identical which may be accurate but is visually useless. Whilst in Izonso you could tell roughly what the enemy may be using based on your knowledge of the class (if required, such as Ice Pick Mountaineers). In Gallipoli everyone on a team can dress identically - cool and all - which causes a problem with identifying what the hell you're up against. This may be a less important point for some people, but readability is important in my opinion. Things being 1HKO means you need to be able to tell at a glance what your opponent may do: be it throw grenades; pull out a bayonet sword and charge or pistol whip you. But with the complete lack of readability and ready abundance of pistols, the only people you're going to be identifying are officers. Who - rightfully, in their case - have pistols. Several of the maps have designs so aggressively bad that I question the intent behind them. Anzac Cove may be historically accurate in its unfairness, but being able to identify on the first time that I play that map that it was going to be a miserable experience every-time for the attacker in the initial phase is ridiculous. Best advice when you see the spawns are boats? Don't spawn. Let the AI rowers and other players get a beach spawn unless you want to be farmed by a HMG that you can barely see. Whilst Anzac Cove and the other one (which I forget, it is slightly better) are definitely the stand outs for 'gods what is this design', several other levels have areas that are so comedically either pro-defender or pro-attacker that once the position is lost you may as well just withdraw rather than counter attack. My last negative point is in regards to the actual gameplay, which in my opinion is a massive downgrade from Izonso and Tannenberg. Whilst I do not dislike it as much as I used to, it is far less smooth and enjoyable to use due to a severely slowed down rifle chamber and more sluggish aim. You'll also spend most of your games either stunned; panicked or being suppressed. None of these are problems on their own, but the sheer amount of it is so excessive that most of the time you'll not be able to aim reliably anyway. Oh, unless you don't go onto the point because you don't want to ruin your unrecorded K/D. Positives are that the game is visually beautiful and the guns sound weighty; HMGs and LMGs are vastly superior to the lasers of death from Izonso; Officers seem to actually get a fun unique kit to play with to be relevant even if Airburst makes me want to cry; the addition of a downed state is subtle enough to not overwrite the lethality of the era and I generally think the main game mode is a slight improvement over Izonso. But if I was to weigh everything together, I'd say get Izonso and wait until Gallipoli's flaws are not as aggressively prominent. TL;DR: too many pistols, too many grenades, customisation and readability bad, some maps bad; gunplay could be better. Officers improvement good, HMGs better, pretty game.

I really wanted to like Gallipoli. I loved Isonzo, and was genuinely excited for this one as it takes place in my country. Unfortunately, in its current state, I can’t recommend it. There are some good ideas here. The lighting and atmosphere are excellent, the new downed system is a nice addition, and the suppression/panic mechanics have potential. When everything works, the game can create some great WW1 moments. The problem is that too much gets in the way. Performance and polish are the biggest issues. Despite delays intended to fix critical bugs, the game still has severe stuttering, desync, awful hit registration and bizarre rendering problems. Enemies, weapons and animations can appear late, teleport or simply fail to render. Desync can make it feel like enemies are playing a second ahead of you. The gunplay is also a major step backward from Isonzo. Rifles there felt accurate, responsive and satisfying. Here, excessive sway, slow ADS, unreliable sights and inconsistent hit registration make them frustrating to use. Pistols feel disproportionately strong, making close-range running and gunning more effective than actually using rifles. I acknowledge that pistols were op during ww1 but this is too much. Suppression takes this even further. Being under fire should make aiming difficult, but the current system can make your weapon sway uncontrollably from a single nearby shot. Combined with poor hit registration, you often feel like you're fighting the mechanics instead of the enemy. The spotting and suppression UI also hurts the immersion. Getting points can effectively tell you where an unseen enemy is, while giant red markers make the game feel more arcade-like than the series' usual authentic WW1 experience. Maps and balance aren't much better. Map design is poorer. Some areas have almost no cover, chokepoints encourage camping, and attacking can feel unnecessarily punishing. Constant artillery and explosions become exhausting rather than immersive, while the lack of useful smoke makes crossing open ground extremely frustrating. Progression and class design also feel weaker than Isonzo, particularly the Officer role. There's simply less to work toward and fewer meaningful moments where good call-ins can change a battle. Overall, Gallipoli feels less like an evolution of Isonzo and more like a step backward. There are good ideas underneath it, but right now they're buried under technical problems, frustrating gunplay, excessive suppression, weak balance and questionable design choices. I hope the developers can turn it around, because the foundation is there. But for now, I'd recommend sticking with Isonzo and waiting for Gallipoli to receive some serious improvements. I might even refund it.

Bu oyunun bizlere sunulmasına vesile olan Çanakkale Savaşları Gelibolu Tarihi Alan Başkanlığı’na ve BlackMill Games’e gerçekten teşekkür etmek lazım. Bu ülkede "yerli oyuna destek" denilerek hak etmeyen yapımlar bile milyonlar satmışken; adamlar ortaklaşa güç birliği yapıp tarihimizi dünyaya en doğru şekilde, üstelik EA Games gibi devlerin yaptığı o taraflı propagandalar olmadan tanıtan muazzam bir işe imza atmışlar. Teşekkür edip sahip çıkılması gerektiği yerde, sırf iki tane ucuz eleştiri yapmak için "Abi vuruş hissi yok ya", "Abi BF1 daha iyi" diyerek oyuna çamur atanlara kafam girsin.

Türkçe seslendirme çok güzel mehter marşı tarzı müziğe bayıldım sizi oyunun içine çekiyor ve Çanakkale haritası çok gerçekçi baya zevk aldım.