
Inspector Smythe from Scotland Yard has informed Watson and me of the murder of General Armstead, a Tontine ticket holder. Something about this case intrigues me. Perhaps it ís that the General was about to publish a scintillating addendum to his infamous book on treasure.
Modeled estimate, not a reported figure. How we estimate →
About
Stats
All-time low is the lowest price we've recorded for this game since we started tracking it.
Languages: English
Engagement
Reviews
Themes across 40 recent reviews and how positive each mention is. A keyword signal, not full sentiment analysis.
Reviews
Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Case of the Tin Soldier is a standout in the Consulting Detective series, and even today, it’s a compelling experience for anyone who enjoys solving intricate mysteries. The story, characters, and gameplay combine to create an engaging detective experience that doesn’t rely on flashy graphics but instead challenges your ability to piece together clues and think critically. Story and Setting This case revolves around the murder of General Armstead, a decorated war veteran found dead under mysterious circumstances. As Holmes, you’ll dig into his life and uncover hidden relationships, secrets, and motives. The Victorian London setting is a perfect backdrop, with all its charm and danger. Every location you visit adds a layer to the atmosphere, immersing you in the gritty world of Holmes and Watson. Gameplay The gameplay follows the established pattern of the series. You’ll navigate a map of London, visit locations, and interview witnesses or suspects. The case doesn’t hand you solutions; instead, it gives you the tools to figure them out on your own. It’s like putting together a puzzle, where each piece is a piece of information—some are useful, some are red herrings. Tips for playing: Take notes: There’s a lot of information to process, and keeping track of names, locations, and motives can save you time later. Read carefully: Every detail in conversations or documents can point you in the right direction. Efficiency matters: The game rewards you for solving the case with minimal visits, so try not to jump around the map too much. Graphics and Presentation The FMV sequences are dated but still have a lot of charm. The performances, while sometimes overly dramatic, suit the tone of the game. The music and sound effects add to the immersion, helping to recreate the mood of Holmes’ world. Replayability and Modern Playability Despite its age, The Case of the Tin Soldier remains enjoyable because of its emphasis on logic and storytelling. Even if you’ve solved it once, you might enjoy replaying to find a more efficient solution. The updated versions available today make it easy to run on modern systems, so there’s no barrier to revisiting this classic. Verdict This is a well-crafted detective story that challenges your reasoning skills while immersing you in the world of Sherlock Holmes. It’s a must-play for fans of mysteries and retro gaming, and it’s still a rewarding experience for newcomers to the series. Highly recommended for anyone who enjoys thoughtful gameplay over flashy visuals.
Media

Related
Related
Price dynamics, follower growth, revenue and sales trajectories with interactive tooltips
This and every other Pro feature is free until October 20, 2026. A free account is all it takes.
Hours played at review time, across 40 reviews with recorded playtime.
positive critical· bar length = how often the theme comes up
It was quite a decent game, if short. It takes a little effort to understand how the game works, but it isn't bad at all once you get the hang of it.
Très bonne enquête ! Je trouve que c'est la meilleure des trois ! En plus de travailler son anglais (l'accent des acteurs est impeccable), on passe un très bon moment en compagnie de nos deux compères Sherlock et Watson, entre fausses pistes et révélations ! Un bon conseil si vous vous y lancez : prenez des notes, elles serviront !
I znów w półtorej godziny udało się rozwiązać kolejną sprawę - tym razem blaszanego żołnierzyka. Bardziej rozbudowana niż sprawa mumii, a równocześnie jakby... łatwiejsza? A może po prostu "wyrabiam się" w pracy detektywa? Tak czy inaczej: polecam!
Short but enjoyable case.
I only recommend this game to those who understand what it is and want his type of game. So, if you know what it is and like it: Go for it! This is a remastering of the old Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective PC game: Same old videos, new Unity 3D engine. The old Consulting Detective PC game, and thus this one, is based on the tabletop Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective, which I find a lot more fun than the PC version(s), but is a lot more expensive and sadly I lost half of my tabletop version before completing all of it. If you can afford the tabletop version, I recommend getting that. If you can't afford it, or just want to stick to the PC, then this could be fun for you. WARNING & NOTE: This is not your typical point & click adventure game. This is a much more complex deduction game. This is closer to a real mystery solving game, than your typical point & click adventure mystery.
the story was pretty good, the end conclusion is always nice to watch. it is way to short again
L'ho rigiocato solo per ricordo dato che è stato uno dei primi titoli della mia era "multimediale" Il lavoro di restauro e i video ad una risoluzione accettabile però fanno perdere completamente il fascino del tempo in cui io vidi per la prima volta i filmati ad un quarto di schermo su una risoluzione di 640x480. A 0.99 euro pure pure, a 3 euro no.
同之前两部,英语好的骨灰级玩家再入手
It was an interesting story and enjoyable use of time. It doesn't necessarily let you pursue clues in the order I would have hoped. But most importantly, ROWLAND/ROLAND is spelled 2 different ways... Which is maddening! Where is the the great Holmes on proofreading!!!?
Selling now
See how fast this game is selling right now — estimated copies and revenue per day from recent review growth.
Players by region
Where this game's players are, estimated from review languages.
Related
| Game | Estimated lifetime revenue | Reviews | Review score | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $4.2M | 8.9K | 92% | $13.99 | |
| $3.7M | 10.4K | 89% | $9.99 | |
| $1.3M | 2K | 83% | $19.99 | |
| $1.2M | 7.5K | 88% | $9.99 | |
| $1.2M | 3.3K | 95% | $12.99 | |
| $768.4K | 1.3K | 63% | $19.99 |
Related
| Game | Estimated lifetime revenue | Reviews | Review score | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $3.3K | 55 | 96% | $3.99 | |
| $3.3K | 55 | 82% | $3.99 | |
| $3.3K | 78 | 91% | $2.99 | |
| $3.3K | 128 | 87% | $1.99 | |
| $3.3K | 128 | 80% | $1.99 | |
| $3.3K | 51 | 69% | $3.99 |