Many Nights a Whisper

Speedrun 7:41.30

Muy buen juego

short, meditative game that waxes philosophical on the burden of expectations. thoroughly enjoyed my time with it!

I am absolutely blown away by the way the narrative pulls you in. The anxiety, the heaviness, the doubt, and the hope all packed into a game that only lasts a few hours. Truly a beautiful little experience

Great emotional and unique story telling done in such a brief playtime.

[h1] Disappointing [/h1] Many Nights a Whisper is a game I should absolutely love, in fact I went into it thinking like many other short narrative focused games that I'd come out of it unable to stop thinking about it for weeks. Instead I rolled credits and felt absolutely nothing. Many Nights a Whisper is a game where you have one shot to fulfill the wishes of an entire town, and your entire life has led up to this one moment. You've hand picked what wishes will come true if you make it even. It's a game that lives or dies by the emotional weight of your choices, and unfortunately it's let down by bad writing and a game mechanic decision that takes away any weight of making those decisions. Past this I will have some light spoilers, so if you want the TLDR without spoilers, the game's wishes are stupid and don't actually make you think at all, and the game has a mechanic that makes you not care about the wishes even less than you already do by tying them to progression. Each night you must listen to wishes from the townsfolk and decide if their wish is one that you would like to have the chance to grant should you make the shot at the final ceremony. These wishes make or break the game even more so than the gameplay in my opinion because if you don't care about the wishes than you have no real reason to care about if you make the shot to make them come true. This is why it's such a shame that these wishes are so incredibly stupid 90% of the time. Looking back at the game I think only 2 wishes made me even stop and contemplate if they should be granted or not. Most wishes boil down to things such as "I wish I could go to hell because my life was too easy" or "I wish I could kill someone I don't like" or "I wish some hot guy loved me". It's the most stupid middle school stuff imaginable. Of the 15ish wishes in the game only 2 stand out to me after finishing it and even these aren't anything crazy thought provoking and one of them is one of the most common "wishes" people have, "I wish my pet lived forever". I didn't even think anything of it until later when the game mentions the possibility of the pet having to watch countless masters die. Perhaps the biggest sin the game makes though is tying the amount of wishes to how strong your slingshot is. The game early on basically tells you if you want any shot of making the final big shot you need to grant enough wishes to upgrade your slingshot. Well this is an extremely stupid choice because it now means you can no longer truly just pick whatever wishes you deem worthy because otherwise you might not even be able to make the shot which your entire life has been leading up to. So great, now you might as well just pick whatever wish isn't just straight up evil because if you don't pick enough of them you've wasted your time. Maybe you can make the point that now you have to deem if these people's pathetic wishes are even worth being granted at all but then you truly have no game and what's the point. Overall, Many Nights a Whisper is a great premise, fantastic even and I was so excited to play it and see what it does with the idea. Unfortunately its let down by awful writing, stupid wishes, and a mechanic that contradicts the whole point of the game. In the end I missed my shot, and felt absolutely nothing. I didn't feel bad for the wishes I failed to grant, I didn't feel disappointed in myself for not practicing enough, I didn't feel like a failure for letting down my mentor and wasting the last 10 years of my life, I just felt absolutely nothing and closed the game without even letting the credits finish. For more reviews, follow my [url=https://store.steampowered.com/curator/40795588-Eggroll-Recommends/] curator page. [/url]

I missed it

不是很推荐也不是完全不推荐，red string和sisterhood之后对这个工作室的期待太高了，前两者的文本量能够撑起一个比较厚重的故事，whisper有点太浮在表面了，不管哪一个topic都没有深入下去，同意有up说像做高考题的感觉...做出的选择没有改变故事的任何一方面...可能是因为单一玩法没办法拓展的的问题吧。 btw，感觉简中的本地化不是特别好，看完英文全流程才get到多一点，但是15块钱要啥自行车。。

Amazing. Must-feel.