Guild Commander

I really enjoy a lot of the story and theme to the game. It also really brings home the pressure you tend to overlook a guild leader being under. I think the game is really well designed and am thoroughly enjoying it. It can be tough to adjust your expectations of progress, but I feel it is properly designed. I give it five stars.

ok

Had high hopes... its a shame really.

Missing a key ingredient...fun.

Весьма интересная игра.

This game is complete garbage. There is no progression and the tutorial video is useless. You need people to go to places but there is no clear designation on where they should be sent. Based on the points in their stats they have you would think that they should be sent to places with that specific designation but apparently no, that is not the case because the majority of the time even when sent to the aligning character stat + location designation they will net zero guild points or monetary income. You spend, what appears to be, an arbitrary amount of money to send characters to different areas. Then they, typically, don't make back that amount of money even if you send them to somewhere that their stats are supposedly good for. They come back all beaten up and low on stats so you spend money on rooms to raise their stats back up but the amount of money going into the room cost and the cost of sending out characters completely dwarfs any kind of income that you receive from the missions that you send them on even if you do happen to get a good paying job. This seems like a situation where the developer played their own game too much and ended up making it overly difficult specifically because they knew exactly how it all worked and didn't take into consideration the learning curve of new players. Also it doesn't start you out slow and work you into it, you have access to every location from the start. So, even though you are an unknown guild you can send people to the far reaches of the kingdom instead of slowly building up your local area and gaining clout there and then expanding your reach little by little. It's not enjoyable to trial and error your way through assigning bad quests without any kind of feedback on whether you are doing it right or not or what kind of progress/affect you are having in the province. Also, the guild floors don't line up properly. I give it 1 silly guild member name out of 6 initially chaotic provinces

L'idée du jeu est bonne, mais mal fichue. Hyper redondant, un challenge soit inexistant soit quasi infranchissable. Le jeu est d'une pauvreté, c'est dommage.