London Detective Mysteria

London Detective Mysteria started out as promising but ultimately fell flat for me. It also took me foreverrrr to finish playing this, because I kept losing the will to continue. But now that I am done. A quick description of this would be.... take Black Butler. Replace Ciel with Elizabeth, and take away the staff that are not Sebastian. Sebastian is now human, but everything else is essentially the same. Now... move that to a high school... and make it mostly standard slice of life, but with some reference to Ciel's sad backstory. Also, Sebastian can never be romanced and is still there taunting you the entire time. (And if you're me, so will a bunch of other characters. None of whom you can date. All of whom seem more enticing.) And no one else is to his standard, because Pendleton is the best. Also, the weird quirks from Black Butler's "setting" remain. with things like Jack the Ripper, one of the Boer Wars, the IRA, and the Second Anglo-Afgan War (I hope it's the second. the 3rd and 1st make even less sense.) coexisting. The slice of life stuff makes the common route so very, very long. It took me 20 hours, and I had to stop waiting for the voice actors to finish speaking to get through it. (Because they talk really slow at points. Ugh. Also dramatic pauses.) If you turn them off right away you'll likely be faster. Some of it is cute, much of it is tedious. Oh, and forget actually solving cases and stuff, you don't really. The game starts by saying you need to remember important details, and gives you a diary to record important things. You'll never need it. except for like. recording some line you maybe want to relisten to because you like that voice actor. Another quick note about voices though. They're equalized badly, so you'll likely need to turn on volume equalization yourself. Also, the sound is inconsistent. The epilogues were a better volume for some characters. I also just. never could get used to the sprites in this. Many of the CGs are really nice! There's also a different art style used in a few that I really liked! But the sprites. Ugh. They're weirdly faded which makes them clash with the backgrounds most of the time, the poses are.. very. posed. stiff. And the eyes. omg, the eyes are awful. The bigger the eye, the more it looks like jelly you could scoop out of the socket. They really bothered me the entire time. TBH the final straw for this is that the grand finale is sequel bait. There was never a sequel made. I'm not even sure I'd want to give the sequel a chance, unless [spoiler]Moriarty Jr.[/spoiler] was a romance option. Or... Pendleton finally? I just can't recommend it unless you're out of other otome to play and don't mind the problems I listed. :< I'd rate this a Meh, but steam does not have a neutral option so... negative it is. Sigh.

I have only one complaint about this game... though it is quite a BIG and SERIOUS complaint indeed... My complaint is; HOW DARE THE WRITERS NOT GIVE PENDLETON A ROUTE!!!!!!!!!!! How dare they create a character as gorgeous and perfect as our dear butler Pendleton, and NOT give him a route of his own!! Every time he appeared, I wanted to cry... it's almost a crime to put our poor hearts through such agony... AGONY!!!!! Apart from that HUGE mistake... I LOVE THIS GAME!! Lol... I love the characters... I love the story line... I love the game! I won't go into detail, so not to give away any spoilers, but it's definitely worth the purchase peeps... so go ahead, tap the PURCHASE button... what are you waiting for!!!!! Then you can also cry and complain about the fact that PENDLETON DOES NOT HAVE A ROUTE along with me, because trust me, you will... XD.

[Updated August 9th, 2019] [Time shown is not accurate - was left running] The common route is satisfyingly long and entertaining during the first run-through. After that, one can use the Skip function, as well as the Go to Last/Next Choice functions, to proceed quickly to the next route/ending. I would prefer a clearer indication of when the "main route" starts, but any guide will tell you. (I'm just stubborn about not using guides until I've done most things on my own, or I think there's a glitch). The game is reminiscent of Code Realize (Otomate), though it is more light-hearted - so far. Given what I've seen from further on in the game, things do get more serious. [Note: They do. Themes include discrimination (race, gender, class, wealth), as well the darker aspects of love, and while there are happy endings, the game doesn't pull its punches as much as I expected.] The main characters are effectively in their final year of high school, so it's not surprising that they seem younger than the Code Realize crowd - they are. I hadn't realized there would be such an English private school background to the first part of the story, but it was enjoyable. That said, and despite the young-looking sprites, the characters are generally well-portrayed as young *adults*, and act accordingly. The protagonist does suffer a little from the "sheltered naive young girl" syndrome of many of these games. However, she does get to be intelligent and brave, and she does have her own story, as well as the story centred on the potential love interest. Overall: the game is well done, the stories and characters are interesting, the art is lovely, and the backgrounds of turn-of-the-century London (late 1800s) are excellent. I will admit that my Agatha Christie loving soul was thrilled to see a Miss Marple to go along with the ubiquitous Holmes and Watson and Lupin(e). Holmes and Watson have their semi-expected roles of tsundere detective and outgoing, engaging partner/assistant. Lupin looks like he'll be interesting, and now that I've played a few routes, I can see that he's as flamboyant in his Gentleman Thief role as ever - only his cover role is (insanely) shy and awkward. I'm looking forward to learning more about the other characters. Pendleton the Butler reminds me of another butler I've 'met' recently, and he's a lot of fun. So far this game has the polish I look for in this type of Japanese otome. I have no regrets about getting the game for the introductory 10% off, and look forward to finishing the routes I have left. ~ Imp

I'm no where near done with this, and already hooked. I have gone way past feeling like I've gotten my money's worth and I've yet to see a single ending with my nearly 10 hours (as of this post) of time spent playing. The writing - story-telling wise - has been entertaining, sharp, and hilarious at times. The Protagonist is, while slightly sheltered, neither dim, nor frustrating, nor amnesiac (which I don't mind, per se, but it happens a lot). She stands as much a detective as the others in a game where everyone has their own strengths and weaknesses. The only jarring thing so far is the spelling. Sometimes it's for someone's accent, but it's not how I think a native English speaker would present such an accent. It's consistent, so you get used to it (or I have already), but it's really the only negative I can say for the game. Well, and the beginning is just a liiiiiiiittle slow, but once you clear the prologue it's a treasure minute by minute. The voice acting is solid, the music is fitting, there's a billion little things I want to know and a few good twists already. It definitely calls out to Code: Realize in terms of Theme, but stands solidly on its own.

[h1]TL;DR:[/h1] Uneven but ultimately well-worth the many hours of investment you'll have into the story & characters. Expect a heavy dose of "anime logic" - like a whole school of brilliant, observant detectives wasn't able to figure out that John Lupine had anything to do with Jean Lupin. --- [h1]Overall Impression:[/h1] IMHO, the opening is very rough. I didn't get a good impression of the MC, nor did I start getting attached to the characters until about 1/4th of the way through my first route. However, once I [i]did[/i] start getting attached, it was strong. Don't expect to actually [i]solve[/i] mysteries. You're rarely quizzed & when you are, most are easy enough that you probably won't have taken notes. If you wish to try to solve the mysteries before the characters, tools are provided, but the game doesn't always give you all of the clues the characters (including the MC!) have at their disposal. The only time it will be useful is when the cryptography puzzle comes in. You're better off following a guide there since you probably won't have the time to solve the puzzles anyway. [h1]Content:[/h1] I'd say that most of the game is PG rated, but there are some areas that take it up to higher levels. - The racism warning is very real. It is only a few short uncomfortable scenes. - Most of the game is very chaste, never going further than kisses & implication things may have happened between scenes, but there is a CG with the MC nude (nothing showing) being embraced by someone protecting her [spoiler]from freezing[/spoiler]. There is some light sexual peril, but nothing that goes beyond statements of intent & being grabbed by attackers. - Violence is heavy. At least PG-13+. Jack the Ripper's real victims are given spotlight in one of the routes, even putting you in their head as they are murdered. All deaths are described pretty vibrantly and these real murders in particular are described in grotesque, fairly historically accurate, detail. Putting yourself in the shoes of real women who were murdered gruesomely may be extremely uncomfortable, but they are treated with respect otherwise. (Excepting their murderer.) - If you are sensitive to weight issues, two characters will frequently remark on the (tiny and petite) heroine's weight. One does it purely as a form of tough love & takes it more to comical territory. The other is a jerk. [h1]Translation/Editing/Technical Issues:[/h1] There were a few typos, but nothing awful. The cockney slang is so thick that it was troublesome to read and, tbh, in places didn't even seem accurately represented. It could have been done in a less heavy-handed manner & been much more enjoyable. I know crashes are possible, but I avoided it by not often using the feature likely to cause them. [h1]Art/Character Design:[/h1] Largely lovely - even gorgeous! - but in some places it could be very awkward. Most of the CGs were well worth the "reward" & they were quite generously handed out. It's unfortunate that it's only a port of a PSP game & larger assets couldn't be used. [h1]The Heroine:[/h1] Her intro was very unflattering. I didn't care for her at all through the prologue. She came off as childish, reckless, not particularly bright, & utterly undeserving of being showered with the queen's favor. I expected to just write her off. But she won me over once she started to gain more of a personality & polish from interacting with the other characters. In most routes, she became utterly charming & quite brilliant. You can absolutely see how she charmed at least five game LIs & warmed the hearts of several others. Her VA was wonderfully expressive. Though sometimes the MC expressed herself in a childish spoiled whine, most of the time she had a very pleasant voice. The emotion the VA could put into a single breathless word really went a long way towards changing my impression of the MC, where the text alone wouldn't have expressed nearly enough. And, of course, there's a world of difference between hearing someone's attempt to soldier through heartbreak & just seeing the words. [h1]The Love Interests:[/h1] I did like all of them. Even the one I liked the least. Keep in mind there are only five romantic routes; the rest are ambiguous. - Marple: (F) for "friendship". This is meant to be the route you get when you fail to romance anyone. I hated it. It was a few "cute" scenes (I found it rather boring, tbh). Then towards the end you realize there was more going on than just "yay friendship". [spoiler]Yan-deredere Miss Marple wants so much to protect her dear friend that she conspires with Holmes to keep Emily from ever pursuing the murders of her family. It's even implied that to do so, Marple will give up her detective dreams as well as sabotaging Emily's to keep her safe.[/spoiler] If you want to treat it as a FxF route after realizing that, then at least treat it as an unhealthy one. - Kobayashi: (B) for boyish hopes. This is another friendship route ending. You can consider it more of a "TBC" than an ending. The only reason I give it a B is because there's little else to it beyond than his trying so hard to protect the hearts of his friends Akeshi & Emily. It's very sweet, though. - Holmes: (D) for d-bag. Don't get me wrong - I liked him in all of the other routes (he made an excellent wingman in some of them, in fact). But in his own route I disliked him quite a lot. His tendency to belittle the heroine's intelligence, weight, & merits was disgusting. Every negative quality he had as a character was in full bloom. The heroine was undermined to the point that she and those close to her remarked how she was less of a person after falling for him (yet they helped them get together...?) Holmes made her dependent on him & smothered her light under his own. The epilogue for his story did some degree of mitigating it, but not by much. I refuse to accept this Holmes as the true Holmes considering he was a better man in the other routes. - Lupin: (B) Rather the opposite of Holmes - I disliked him (sometimes intensely) in most of the other routes. But in his own, it's probably the most "flowery" of all the romances, even if he was often a scoundrel. I liked him best in his epilogue. YMMV on Lupin probably more-so than any other character. - Akeshi: (A) If you're into the diligent, straight-laced type, he's an amazing example of it. I found him utterly sweet, dependable, & admirable. He had stiff competition or he would normally rank higher. - Watson: (A+) If you're into the adorable good-boy types, he is that in spades. I played his route first & "fell" so hard for him that I was reluctant to leave him. It honestly pained me a bit to pursue other routes seeing how honestly in love he was with Emily in even the other routes. (All of the LIs were to some extent, but their love was more reserved than Watson's.) - Jack: (S) I can't honestly say it's the [i]best[/i] route in the game - but it was the one that finally upset Watson's ranking as my favorite. His feelings for Emily were at least on par with Watson's & it made me so happy that [spoiler]they effectively became the best broTP in the game[/spoiler]. His route was the most dark & violent, but was the most satisfying for me. [h1]Story:[/h1] It's a strange mixture of extremely clever writing that asks the reader to think & feel every subtle emotional beat + "anime logic" that tells you to just turn your brain off & go with the flow. There are so many plotholes & loose ends (presumably left open for the intended sequel that may never arrive) that I should do a tableflip over it but... I liked it in the end. Get through the brain-dead opening scene & keep going. There are some real gems in there & most of the routes were good - & a few truly special. [h1]In closing...[/h1] I genuinely hope that the sequel teased in the epilogue one day becomes a thing.

I haven't finished every route in London Detective Mysteria yet, but I am already in love with it! Initially, I thought it was too expensive, but the moment I started the game I knew it was worth the price. With lengthy chapters, immersive dialogue, and clever banter, you will find yourself completely engaged and wanting more! If you're concerned about how some reviews claim the love interests do all of the actual detective work while the protagonist (Emily) does nothing, I have to disagree. Emily is a reflective and analytical individual, curious about the darkness of London outside of her noble bubble. She contributes quite a lot to their cases (unlike some...I'm looking at you 7Scarlet), and her own noble perspective often aids them in investigations. EDIT: (finished game) She learns and grows uniquely in each route (unlike Hakuoki, where each good route has the same formula) and this is the first otome game where I have enjoyed each character route and feel attached to every love interest. Another concern I noticed when buying was that other reviews say they were left feeling unsatisfied with the grand ending. I cannot speak to this, but I'm willing to sacrifice my time for a disappointing ending 1. because I will still love the characters forever and 2. I am already scarred with how ridiculously repetitive, insulting, and anticlimactic Men of Yoshiwara was with each and every ending. #BoughtMyHusband Lastly, if you just like the idea of living in Victorian England and being privileged enough to be a woman attending a detective college as ordered by the Queen, all while questioning whether you will align yourself with the law or with love as you meet handsome men throughout your journey, then this game is for you! EDIT: Since this review I have not only finished the game, but replayed both Jack and Holmes' routes multiple times! This is my favorite otome game ever and I was very satisfied with the grand ending. My favorite thing is how diverse the routes are in their plots and endings. I also appreciate the fact that once you choose your love interest, the other characters don't simply disappear. They remain you friends (and sometimes your wingman!) and support you in solving the mystery at hand until the very end. London Detective Mysteria is a heart-warming game that leaves you with that good feeling when you finish a thrilling romance novel. EDIT 2: Still love this game <3

I just couldn't get into it. It probably isn't that bad but it's also not good enough so that I want to put my time in it... The game would be okay if i was 14-16 years old maybe. There aren't romance options for people that are 20+

Steam really needs a "lukewarm" review option. Seeing as my more "luke" than "warm" on this game I'll have to put down a not recommended. This game has a lot of potential, but it felt like it couldn't decide if it wanted to be a mystery vn or otome and in trying to encompass both genres fell flat. The common route felt too long (the first time I played it I lost interest half way through), and I think it would have been better splitting some of it into character routes instead, because by the time you get to a character route, that feels very short. Plus once you get to character routes, most have very limited choices for you to make and you don't really participate at all. Some of the sprites, particularly for villains or side characters look like they're half finished (what is going on with Porlok's neck / scarf? Straight up the thing of nightmares). The MC seems to have moments of clarity or realisation about their actions, and resolves to do better, but then in the next scene does exactly the same thing; which is at best disappointing, and at worst, feels like poor writing. That out of the way, most of the CGS are quite beautiful and the individual routes that I've gone so far have been very charming. The epilogues are sweet too. Once you get through the common route the first time you can always use the skip to try other characters routes so that's a bonus. It's quite straight forward and not a high risk game so it's good for casual playing. I would probably recommend picking this up on sale if you want to try it out.