Yi Xian: The Cultivation Card Game

（请向下滚动阅读中文版本） Dear Yi Xian Team, Your game is quite possibly one of the best autobattlers on the market. I love Yi Xian — your ideas are brilliant, the game is pretty well balanced, and it genuinely has a super strong "easy to learn, hard to master" skill curve. HUGE RESPECT for your beautiful art style (shoutout to the game artists) and the perfectly clean game design. Brilliant! I'm a game developer (Europe), and I'm convinced that with the following adjustments your game could truly become the number one in the autobattler genre. PLEASE remove counter mechanics that are based purely on luck. Example: there's barely any way to react to card skipping. Neither I nor my opponent knows where the other is going to place their cards. Even if I keep in mind that they could theoretically trigger a skip, where you end up placing it is pure gambling in the end — at least in high elo. The same goes for other counter mechanics, e.g. anti-chase. Most chase combos can't suddenly rebuild anyway, since you naturally lack the filler cards — and if you hold onto those filler cards, you're at a massive statistical disadvantage for the entire game. Please keep the focus on building up your own board rather than destroying your opponent's. It feels really, really bad, especially when you're playing in the top 100. Please fix your UI and user guidance. Events are great, but why do there have to be 10 different corners where you scrape together 5 different currencies (all active at the same time)? It's extremely tedious. I'd much rather see the focus on one really good, clean event instead of five. Definitely fix the UI — make everything more minimalist and cleaner (your art style is so incredibly beautiful, and you can absolutely keep that as traditional as it is). Server fixes. At times — at least in Europe — the game freezes for 10-30 seconds mid-round. That obviously breaks the game instantly, especially when you're hyper rolling. This season is currently really strong. The new features integrate into the classic game incredibly well. PLEASE leave out things like the old "Dream Cards" in the future — they just end up being temporary throwaway content. Build your game out in breadth rather than always going deep for just a single season. My dream scenario would be for you to fix the game on these few points, then bring a big investor on board and take the whole thing one level further. Card-specific animations, modern VFX with the old charm, maybe modern full-art cards (while still preserving your perfect art style). When you're ready, let me know — I know quite a few investors who are looking for exactly this kind of project. All in all, the only reason I'm giving this much feedback is that I really believe you currently have the game with the biggest potential on the market. 亲爱的《弈仙牌》(Yi Xian)开发团队: 你们的游戏可以说是目前市面上最好的卡牌自走棋游戏之一。我真的很喜欢《弈仙牌》，你们的创意非常精彩，游戏平衡性做得相当不错，而且真的做出了那种"易学难精"的超强上手曲线。你们的美术风格真的太赞了(向美术同学致敬!)，游戏设计干净利落，堪称完美。太强了!我本人是一名(欧洲的)游戏开发者，我很确定只要做以下几点调整，你们的游戏真的有机会成为自走棋品类的NO.1。 拜托把那种纯靠运气的counter机制拿掉。举个例子:对于"跳过卡牌"这个机制，几乎没有办法做出有效的应对。无论是我还是对手，都不知道对方到底会把牌放在哪里。就算我记住对方理论上可能会选择跳过，但最后到底放在哪个位置，说到底还是纯粹看运气，尤其是在高分段的时候更是如此。 其他的counter机制也是同样的问题，比如anti-chase(反追杀)机制——本来大部分追杀combo一旦开局就几乎不可能临时改打法，因为缺少足够的凑数牌(filler卡)，而如果强行保留这些牌不动，整局游戏在数值/概率上就会处于巨大劣势。请务必把重心放在"搭建自己的阵容"上，而不是"拆对手的阵容"，这种被针对的感觉真的很难受，尤其是打到前100名的时候。 拜托修一下UI和引导流程。活动本身很棒，但为什么非要跑到10个不同的地方，去凑齐5种(而且还是同时并行的)货币呢?这真的很繁琐。与其做5个活动，不如专注做好1个真正干净利落的活动。UI这块真的要好好整理一下，做得更简约、更清爽一些(你们的美术风格本身已经美到不行了，完全可以在保留那种传统韵味的前提下做到更简洁)。 服务器方面也得修一下。至少在欧洲这边，游戏经常会在一局对局中卡个10-30秒。这种情况下，尤其是在hyper roll的时候，整局体验直接就毁了。 这个赛季真的做得很强，新feature和经典玩法的结合度高得惊人。拜托以后不要再做那种类似旧版"Dream Card"那样，纯粹只是一次性用完就丢的临时产物了。把游戏往"广度"上做，而不是每个赛季都只顾着往"深度"上短期猛冲。 我心里最大的愿望，是你们能把游戏按上面这几点修好之后，找一个大投资方，然后把整个项目再往上提升一个层次。比如做一些专属卡牌动画、带点复古味道的现代VFX，甚至可以考虑做现代化的满绘卡(但同时保留你们现在这套完美的美术风格)。等你们准备好的时候，欢迎联系我，我认识几位正在寻找这类项目的投资人。 总而言之，我给出这么多反馈，正是因为我真心觉得，你们现在做的这款游戏，是市面上潜力最大的一款。